Tag Archives: Hamas

An Israeli’s thoughts on Palestinian unity.

And thus my regular column at The Daily Beast/Zion Square begins! I’ll be running a post every other Friday, starting today (in addition to the occasional one-off piece, such as the one that ran on launch day).

You’ll find the top of today’s entry below — I suspect it will win me few friends, but there it is. One doesn’t get into the poorly-paying having-opinions-about-Israel/Palestine biz in order to win friends.

To read the whole thing, I encourage you to click here — and just like I did last week, I really mean it: Please click! (And of course: FB, Tweet, Stumble, Pin, Digg, etc, and so on. Tell your friends! Is what I’m saying here). I would surely take it as a kindness.

You Don’t Make Peace With Your Friends

I was at the grocery store on Arlozorov Street one bright spring morning in 1997. Tel Aviv was gearing up for Purim, so I likely had hamentaschen in the cart, certainly challah and probably milk. I was, no doubt, staring into the middle distance when I began to notice a certain agitation animating the store’s elderly security guard. He crossed the store and began to speak in urgent tones with his manager, radio in hand.

In Israel, these are signs that “mashehu kara,” something’s happened – and by “something” folks mean: an attack, rockets, Israeli death at Arab hands.

The security guard, it transpired, had heard news of another suicide bombing – but this one was literally around the corner from my apartment. On that spring day, three young mothers, out for coffee, were killed at the now-infamous Apropos Restaurant.

Continue reading

TumblrShare

Gilad Shalit comes home, & the two-state solution dies.

Gilad Shalit is embraced by his father, Noam, immediately after his return to Israel.

Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit is home today, in his mother’s and father’s arms, his physical wounds receiving treatment, his other wounds no doubt just beginning to emerge. But he’s home. And that is a very, very good thing, and it’s good aside from and beyond anything else. Nothing I write here or anywhere else changes that. I am trying to hold that in my mind even as I consider all of the horror that surrounds that one, shining, good thing.

Last week, I wrote about some of what’s been wrong in Israel’s response to Shalit’s capture from day one — from day-minus-one, actually, given the Israeli kidnapping of two Gazan men from their homes, one day before Shalit was captured (in uniform and on duty) by Palestinian militants.

Today I’m going to write about what is so frightening and heartbreaking about the implications of the whole, broader story in which Shalit plays a part.

Continue reading

TumblrShare

Yup – Hamas is a terrorist organization. Now what?

Please note update, below.

I’m frequently asked about Hamas with regard to the Israeli-Palestinian peace process, and this past week has certainly been no exception. The questions take many forms, but they tend to boil down to this very reasonable query: “Hamas is a terrorist organization. How do you make peace with a terrorist organization?” Following is a bulked-up version of an email that I sent last night, in answer to that very question.

There’s no doubt that Hamas is a terrorist organization. Indeed, when I lived in Tel Aviv, they tried to kill me — by sending people to blow themselves up on buses that I rode frequently, and in the middle of a cafe just two half-blocks from my home. I had to cover several of those stories as a newspaper reporter, and I would be lying if I said that doing so wasn’t a particular kind of awful. Seeing what I saw, and knowing that the perpetrators would have been just as happy to have my blood join the blood that was splashed across the sidewalk before me didn’t always leave me feeling particularly even-keeled.

So, yeah. No love from me for Hamas.
Continue reading

TumblrShare

Dear Israel: Your house is on fire, & you’re worried about the pilot light.

Palestinian family fleeing fighting, 1948. Source: http://imeu.net/

Just as the establishment of the State of Israel was a big deal for the Jewish people, it was a big deal for the Palestinians. Only for them, the outcome was a little less uplifting.

I’m on record all over the place — on this blog, on my Twitter account, in the archives of America’s op/ed pages, in the transcripts of lectures, and even on the occasional bit of video tape — as being a Zionist. I have no doubt that, as long as the modern world is organized along nationalist lines, the Jewish people has as much a right to a homeland as anyone else — and that furthermore, that homeland can only be genuinely found in the land that stood at the center of the Jewish people’s identity for centuries.

At the same time, however, I am also on record (in all those places) as recognizing that the land that belongs to the Jews also belongs equally to someone else.

The Palestinians were already experiencing the birth of their own modern nationalist identity (see today’s earlier post, re: Rashid Khalidi’s Palestinian Identity) when the Zionists came along to pursue Jewish nationalist goals. The ensuing war (which, let’s be honest, continues to this day) has been the result of two clashing nationalisms, and the people behind each behaved exactly as one might expect people fighting for their homes and their lives to behave — that is: abominably.

But bottom line, to the extent that the war has yet produced a victor, that victor is Israel. We have a state; the Palestinians don’t. We control our destinies; the destinies of Palestinians living in Palestine are controlled by Israel. And so on.

Thus: One people’s joyous event is another’s day of national sorrow. If the Palestinians had won, I have no doubt everybody’s shoes would be on the other feet.

Israel celebrates Independence Day according to the Hebrew calendar — meaning it shifts about in the spring every year — but Palestinians mark Yawm al-Nakba, Day of the Catastrophe on May 15th, the anniversary of the establishment of Israel. This fact is no doubt uncomfortable for those who like to celebrate Israel’s birth, and I can understand why some would feel the need to try to tell the Palestinians that their lived reality is a bunch of lies and prevarications. Such is the nature of people — holding two opposing ideas in our minds at one and the same time is nothing if not painful.

But the thing is: Declaring a series of facts to not be facts doesn’t actually change their factual nature. It merely puts off the inevitable reckoning with those facts, and, in the case of armed conflict, tends to add to the body count. This is as true for Israelis who deny the Palestinian narrative, as it is for Palestinians who deny the Jewish narrative.

Continue reading

TumblrShare

Israel, this is insanity. And abject failure.

Aftermath of an Israeli air raid, Gaza, 2009.

For as long as I can remember, Israel has been saying that it was going to do “whatever it takes” to stop Palestinian terrorism.

On Thursday, an Israeli bus filled with kids was hit by an anti-tank missile fired out of Gaza. Two were injured, including a 16 year old boy who may well die of his injuries; there is some indication that those who fired on the bus knew that it was transporting students.

The Israeli military responded with intensified bombing of the Gaza Strip (it should be noted that Israel frequently runs bombing raids over Gaza, sometimes in direct response to violence, sometimes not, and has in fact been strafing Gaza off and on over the past several weeks at least), resulting in five Palestinians killed, including a 50 year old man, and five injured, including a young child.

In a statement that surprised exactly no one (and probably did little to reassure anyone), Prime Minister Netanyahu said: “We will not shy away from taking all the necessary action, offensive and defensive, to protect our country and to protect our citizens.”

Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu, circa 2011? I’d like you to meet Israeli President Ezer Weizman, circa 1994: Continue reading

TumblrShare